The Pharisees demand a sign
11 The Pharisees came and began to question Jesus. To test him, they asked him for a sign from heaven. 12 He sighed deeply and said, “Why does this generation ask for a sign? Truly I tell you, no sign will be given to it.” 13 Then he left them, got back into the boat and crossed to the other side.
8th October 2024: Paphos, Cyprus
These few verses come hot on the heels of the feeding of the 4000 at the beginning of Chapter 8. ,This was surely one of the greatest signs of the power, authority and compassion of Jesus.
After that miracle, Jesus has dismissed the crowd, and then crossed the Lake, coming ashore at Dalmanutha, a short distance south of his home town of Capernaum. Almost before he has got out of the boat, Jesus is confronted by some Pharisees. If we read the companion verses in Matthews Gospel (Matthew 16:1-4), we read that these Pharisees were in the company of Sadducees. The beliefs of these two groups of deeply religious people were very different from one another. There is a lesson here, that those who are opposed to Christ will often join forces with others, setting aside their differences to attack him and those who follow him.
There was a contemporary religious view that miracles were real, but came in two forms. Miracles were either achieved by the deceiving power of the devil, or by the power of God. There are lots of examples, even in Scripture, of ‘magicians’ performing miracles (a good example would be Exodus 8, where Pharaoh’s magicians replicate some of Moses miracles (Exodus 8:5-8). These were regarded as being performed in the power of Satan. An example of a miraculous sign from God (there are lots of these too), would be 2 Kings 20:9-11 , which records the sun briefly moving backwards to affirm a promise of God. These are huge, powerful signs which were beyond the scope of the most highly skilled magician. These were truly signs from heaven.
The Jewish leaders are looking for a powerful and undisputable sign of such magnitude that the weather is impacted, or perhaps fire falls from heaven before them.
In Matthew 12:24, the Jews accused Jesus of drawing his power from the devil. ‘It is only by Beelzebul, the prince of demons, that this fellow drives out demons.’ They are, in effect, acknowledging that Christ has performed miracles, but they are suggesting that none of them demonstrate the power of God. Jesus is being attacked here. The claim is that these miracles demonstrate that Jesus is drawing on the power of Satan. They will not believe otherwise unless they personally witness what they regard as a ‘proper’ miracle. If you can do that kind of miracle – we’ll believe.
These are deeply religious people. They believe that they are right. They have heard, perhaps even witnessed – the miracles of Jesus, but they demand more. Give us more, bigger and better, and then perhaps we’ll believe. Their attack is venomous. They mean business. They are deeply self righteous people.
At their demand, Jesus sighs. The word is unusual in Scripture and means a deep, emotional, heartfelt sigh. A sigh, perhaps, of exasperation. ‘What is it,’ says Jesus, ‘with this generation, that they think they need a sign.‘ These people know Scripture. They know about Jesus and the many signs which have already been given. They even know how to read the signs of the weather {Matthew 16:1-4). They know that the people are excited by talk of miracles of healing, deliverance, and the feeding huge crowds of people. The Pharisees and Sadducees may not have seen everything they want to see, but they have seen much more than they need to see.
The signs are all around them. Will Jesus give them another sign? A greater, bigger, better sign? His answer is simple. No.
With his disciples, Jesus gets back in the boat and moves on.
Richard Jackson, West Sussex: LifePictureUK